Monthly Archives: September 2008

Several years ago my son cut himself at work. Fortunately he received only a minor injury. He went to a local university hospital where a nice medical student cleaned his wound and gave him two stitches. He did not see a physician- ever- during that visit. As a practicing physician in another university hospital I wasn’t terribly concerned until I got a bill from the hospital and the physician.

There were two problems with the bills. The first was that both bills were in excess of the contractually allowed amount under my insurance coverage (both the physician and hospital in-network providers on my insurance). The other problem is that physicians may not collect for services they don’t actually provide.

The hospital tried what is commonly know as balance billing. I had read my insurance contract so I knew it was prohibited. I can read an EOB (explanation of benefits) so I understood where all the charges were coming from and what was permitted. The physician was, incontrast, committing fraud. Being a knowledgeable physician and consumer I called the hospital and the physcian’s office. Although I spent quite a bit of time on hold with both I eventually got the physician bill dropped altogether (I also informed the insurance company so they wouldn’t pay either). The hospital reduced the bill to something entirely reasonable.

Most insurance companies do not allow in-network hospitals or physicians to balance bill patients. Patients have an obligation to understand the EOB and only pay what is required. Patient must carefully read and understand their insurance contract. If you have questions call your insurance company.

It’s your health and your money. Protect them both.

Sometimes the government actually works. Recently the Federal Trade Commission files charges against eleven companies for marketing bogus “cures” for cancer. Some readers may view this as decreasing the options for the seriously ill. In fact most patients are poorly positioned to evaluate the scientific merit of medical claims. (Many will recall the cost effectiveness analysis of “consciousness” monitoring presented here previously.) Like consciousness monitoring these cancer “cures” fail the first requirement for cost effectiveness- they don’t actually cure anything- except the poverty of the companies responsible for selling these products.

The FTC has made an excellent and timely move.

Readers know how I feel about hospitals and physicians being paid for services they don’t perfom or perform inadequately. Readers also know that it’s call fraud to bill for such services. The Staten Island University Hospital will pay $89 million in fines to settle fraud charges arising from illegal activities over an 8 year period. That’s MILLION dollars. That’s EIGHT years of illegal activity. That’s readers’ tax dollars being illegally obtained and used.

It is critical that patients carefully examine every bill they receive from a healthcare provider. Compare your EOB (Explanation of Benefits) with the bill and make sure you received everything you were billed for.

It’s your healthcare and your healthcare dollars. Participate activily and use them wisely.

We’ve been delayed here at Aegis. Our offices are relocating and we’ve been without all of our services. We’re about to get unpacked and back up to speed shortly. Stay tuned for more.

We here at Aegis have noted before that American medicine is often not very good. There’s unresolved conflicts of interest. There’s physicians, hospitals, administrators, and for-profit corporations all with a hand out asking for your healthcare dollar.

It’s easy to say that we need a single-payer system and that the single payer should be the government. We need only look as far England’s National Health Service (NHS) to realize that might be little better. Recently NICE the NHS’s healthcare rationing division apologized for failing to approve treatments that would have spared the sight of NHS patients.

It still comes down to some simple economics. Everyone cannot have every treatment every time. Patients must take an active role in their own healthcare and demand answers and explanations from providers.

It’s your health take it seriously and stay involved.